Causes of high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential under HVDC interference and influencing factors
-
摘要: 基于實際的工程參數建立了高壓直流干擾電場計算模型，利用數值模擬計算技術對高壓直流干擾大幅值管地電位的產生原因進行探究。考察接地極與管道之間的間距、管道防腐層類型、管道長度及土壤結構等因素對高壓直流干擾下管地電位的影響規律，得到高壓直流干擾大幅值管地電位是在接地極與管道距離較近、防腐層的絕緣性能較高、管道長度較大及上低下高的土壤電阻率分層結構共同作用下產生的。Abstract: Since the 1950s, international studies have confirmed the technical advantages of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission projects, such as large capacity, low loss, and high stability. In recent years, due to the reverse distribution of energy demand and resources in China, large-scale long-distance transportation of energy is inevitable. HVDC is especially suitable for large-scale transmission projects such as “west to east power transmission” and “north to south power transmission.” Therefore, a number of HVDC projects have been built in China since the 1980s. However, with the large-scale construction of HVDC transmission projects, the interference effect of HVDC grounding electrode on metal facilities is increasingly prominent, in which the buried pipeline will produce high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential under HVDC interference. As a result, HVDC interference can cause damage to pipelines, personnel, and related equipment. However, there is no systematic analysis of the causes of high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential at home and at abroad. Based on the actual engineering parameters, this paper established a calculation model of the high-voltage direct current interference electric field on the buried pipeline and a numerical simulation technology was used to explore the causes of the high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential under HVDC interference. Moreover, the influence of the distance between the grounding electrode and the pipeline, the type of anti-corrosion coating, the length of the pipeline, and the soil structure on the pipe ground potential under HVDC interference was investigated. Results reveal that the high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential under HVDC interference is under the joint action of the short distance between the grounding electrode and the pipeline, the high insulation performance of the anti-corrosion layer, the large length of the pipeline, and the soil layered structure with low resistivity at upper and high resistivity at lower.
-
Key words:
- HVDC /
- high amplitude of pipe-to-soil potential /
- causes /
- influencing factors /
- simulation calculation
-
圖 1 接地極與管道相對位置示意圖
Figure 1. Diagram of relative position between the grounding electrode and pipeline
圖 2 模型計算結果與現場數據匹配圖
Figure 2. Matching diagram of model calculation results and field data
圖 3 高壓直流干擾中Esoil、Epipe和Epipe-to-soil三種計算電位示意圖
Figure 3. Diagram of the three calculated potentials of Esoil, Epipe, and Epipe-to-soil under HVDC interference
圖 4 基礎模型中管道沿線兩種電位計算結果。（a）Esoil；（b）Epipe
Figure 4. Calculation results of two potentials along the pipeline in the validation model: (a) Esoil; (b) Epipe
圖 5 接地極周圍土壤電位沿線分布圖
Figure 5. Distribution of soil potential around the grounding electrode
圖 6 高壓直流干擾時不同垂直間距下管道沿線三種電位計算結果。（a）Esoil；（b）Epipe；（c）Epipe-to-soil
Figure 6. Calculation results of three types of potential along the pipeline under different vertical spacings under HVDC interference: (a) Esoil; (b) Epipe; (c) Epipe-to-soil
圖 7 高壓直流干擾時不同防腐層下管道沿線三種電位計算結果。（a）Esoil；（b）Epipe；（c）Epipe-to-soil
Figure 7. Calculation results of three types of potential along the pipeline under different anticorrosive coatings under HVDC interference: (a) Esoil; (b) Epipe; (c) Epipe-to-soil
圖 8 高壓直流干擾時不同管道長度下管道沿線三種電位計算結果。（a）Esoil；（b）Epipe；（c）Epipe-to-soil
Figure 8. Calculation results of three types of potential along the pipeline under different pipeline lengths under HVDC interference: (a) Esoil; (b) Epipe; (c) Epipe-to-soil
圖 9 高壓直流干擾時不同底層土壤電阻率下管道沿線三種電位計算結果。（a）Esoil；（b）Epipe；（c）Epipe-to-soil
Figure 9. Calculation results of three potentials along the pipeline under different bottom soil resistivities under HVDC interference: (a) Esoil; (b) Epipe; (c) Epipe-to-soil
圖 10 不同底層與表層土壤電阻率之比下管道中心處Esoil、Epipe和Epipe-to-soil分布圖
Figure 10. Distribution of Esoil, Epipe, and Epipe-to-soil in the center of the pipeline under the ratio of soil resistivity of different bottom and surface layers
表 1 管道參數
Table 1. Pipe parameters
Parameters Outer radius
of pipe /
mmWall thickness /
mmDepth /
mVertical distance between the pipeline and grounding electrode / km Resistivity of anticorrosive coating / (Ω·m2) Pipe length /
kmBasic model 400 50 2 7 105 185 Vertical distance between the pipeline and grounding electrode 400 50 2 1/3/5/10 105 100 Pipeline anticorrosive coating 400 50 2 5 0/104/105 100 Pipe length 400 50 2 5 105 1/5/10/30/50/100 Soil structure 400 50 2 5 105 100 
下載: 導出CSV
表 2 高壓直流接地極參數
Table 2. Parameters of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) grounding electrode
Current in monopolar
mode / AStructure Radius of outer
ring / mRadius of inner
ring / mDepth /
m3200 Dual-loop structure 315 240 3.5
下載: 導出CSV
表 3 土壤結構參數
Table 3. Soil structure parameters
Layers Thickness/m Resistivity/(Ω·m) First layer 2.5 25 Second layer 8.1 60.5 Third layer ∞ 790
下載: 導出CSV
中文字幕在线观看表 4 土壤結構計算的分層情況
Table 4. Layering of the soil structure calculation
No. First layer soil
resistivity/
(Ω·m)Second layer soil
resistivity/
(Ω·m)Third layer soil
resistivity/
(Ω·m)Ratio of bottom
to topsoil
resistivity1 25 60.5 5 0.2:1 2 25 60.5 12.5 0.5:1 3 25 60.5 25 1:1 4 25 60.5 50 2:1 5 25 60.5 100 4:1 6 25 60.5 300 12:1 7 25 60.5 800 32:1 8 25 60.5 1500 60:1 9 25 60.5 3000 120:1
下載: 導出CSV
-
參考文獻
[1] Zhao W J. HVDC Engineering Technology. Beijing: China Electric Power Press, 2004趙畹君. 高壓直流輸電工程技術. 北京: 中國電力出版社, 2004 [2] Liao M F, Zhang X L, Xing X Y, et al. Research status and development trend of grounding current effect of UHVDC grounding electrode on corrosion of the metal pipelines. High Voltage Apparatus, 2018, 54(7): 44廖敏夫, 張曉莉, 邢小羽, 等. 特高壓直流接地極入地電流對金屬管道腐蝕研究現狀與發展趨勢. 高壓電器, 2018, 54(7):44 [3] Cao G F, Gu Q L, Jiang Y T, et al. Current interference of HVDC ground electrode to buried pipelines and its personal safety distance. Nat Gas Ind B, 2019, 6(5): 427 doi: 10.1016/j.ngib.2019.03.001 [4] Zhou Y, Jiang Z T, Ma X M, et al. Case analysis on corrosion and protection of onshore oil and gas pipeline interfered by HVDC earth electrode. J Saf Sci Technol, 2019, 15(7): 156周毅, 姜子濤, 馬學民, 等. 陸上油氣管道受高壓直流接地極干擾的腐蝕與防護實例分析. 中國安全生產科學技術, 2019, 15(7):156 [5] Wang Z G, Wang W J, Wang F Q, et al. Research on the corrosion effect of the UHVDC ground electrode current on the metal pipelines // IEEE International Conference on Power and Renewable Energy. Shanghai, 2016: 48 [6] Bi W X, Chen H Y, Li Z J, et al. HVDC interference to buried pipeline: numerical modeling and continuous P/S potential monitoring // CORROSION 2016. Vancouver, 2016: NACE-2016-7714 [7] Jiang Z T, Cao G F, Ge C G, et al. Study on the mechanism and influencing factors of HVDC interference // CORROSION 2017. New Orleans, 2017: NACE-2017-9293 [8] Li X Y. HVDC System. Beijing: Science and Technology Press, 2010李興源. 高壓直流輸電系統. 北京: 科學技術出版社, 2010 [9] Li Z J. Field test and analysis of interference of high or ultra high voltage direct current transmission system to underground steel pipeline. Corros Prot, 2017, 38(2): 142 doi: 10.11973/fsyfh-201702012李振軍. 高壓/特高壓直流輸電系統對埋地鋼質管道干擾的現場測試與分析. 腐蝕與防護, 2017, 38(2):142 doi: 10.11973/fsyfh-201702012 [10] Qin R Z, Du Y X, Jiang Z T, et al. Research status of interference of HVDC transmission system to buried metal pipeline. Corros Sci Prot Technol, 2016, 28(3): 263秦潤之, 杜艷霞, 姜子濤, 等. 高壓直流輸電系統對埋地金屬管道的干擾研究現狀. 腐蝕科學與防護技術, 2016, 28(3):263 [11] Wu J W, Song P. Influence of the high voltage ground current on buried pipeline’s potential. J Electr Eng, 2017, 5(2): 196吳江偉, 宋鵬. 高壓入地電流對埋地管道電位的影響. 電氣工程, 2017, 5(2):196 [12] Li Z L. Interference and protection on buried pipeline of high voltage direct current grounding electrode. Pipeline Technol Equip, 2017(3): 39 doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9614.2017.03.013李兆玲. 高壓直流接地極對埋地管道的干擾與防護. 管道技術與設備, 2017(3):39 doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-9614.2017.03.013 [13] Gong Y, Xue C L, Yuan Z L, et al. Advanced analysis of HVDC electrodes interference on neighboring pipelines. J Power Energy Eng, 2015, 3: 332 doi: 10.4236/jpee.2015.34045 [14] Qin R Z, Du Y X, Jiang Z T, et al. Corrosion behavior of X80 pipe steel under HVDC interference in sandy soil. Metals, 2018, 8(10): 809 doi: 10.3390/met8100809 [15] Qin R Z, Du Y X, Xu Z C, et al. Anodic polarization behavior of X80 steel in Na2SO4 solution under high potential and current density conditions. Materials, 2019, 12(3): 394 doi: 10.3390/ma12030394 [16] Ying B. The influence of HVDC grounding electrode on the safe operation of long-distance pipeline. Oil-Gasfield Surf Eng, 2014, 33(7): 23 doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-6896.2014.7.015應斌. 高壓直流輸電系統接地極對長輸管道安全運行的影響. 油氣田地面工程, 2014, 33(7):23 doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-6896.2014.7.015 [17] Tan C B, Xu G, Xu M Z, et al. Effect of monopolar earth-return operation of grounding electrode on natural gas pipelines. Oil Gas Storage Transp, 2018, 37(6): 670譚春波, 許罡, 許明忠, 等. 接地極單極大地回路電流運行對天然氣管道的影響. 油氣儲運, 2018, 37(6):670 [18] Sun J G, Cao G F, Han C C, et al. Influence of HVDC transmission system ground electrode on West-East Gas Pipeline. Corros Prot, 2017, 38(8): 631 doi: 10.11973/fsyfh-201708012孫建桄, 曹國飛, 韓昌柴, 等. 高壓直流輸電系統接地極對西氣東輸管道的影響. 腐蝕與防護, 2017, 38(8):631 doi: 10.11973/fsyfh-201708012 [19] Zha X T, Zhang J W, Chen S L, et al. Corrosion behavior of carbon steel in interference of stray current and cathodic protection. Surf Technol, 2015, 44(12): 12查鑫堂, 張建文, 陳勝利, 等. 雜散電流干擾和陰極保護作用下碳鋼腐蝕規律研究. 表面技術, 2015, 44(12):12 [20] Nicholson P. High voltage direct current interference with underground/underwater pipelines // Corrosion 2010. San Antonio, 2010: NACE-2010-10102 [21] Fowles D T. Effects of HVDC on cast-iron pipe systems. J AWWA, 1971, 63(4): 233 doi: 10.1002/j.1551-8833.1971.tb04072.x [22] Qin R Z, Du Y X, Peng G Z, et al. High voltage direct current interference on buried pipelines: case study and mitigation design // CORROSION 2017. New Orleans, 2017: NACE-2017-9049 [23] Qing P. Research on Influence of HVDC Ground Electrode Current on High-speed Railway Traction Net [Dissertation]. Beijing: North China Electric Power University, 2016青攀. 高壓直流接地極電流對高鐵牽引網的影響硏究[學位論文]. 北京: 華北電力大學, 2016 [24] Nejad B M, Blumhagen L. Inductive interference from HVDC transmission lines on close proximity pipeline segments // CORROSION 2018. Phoenix, 2018: NACE-2018-10913 -
點擊查看大圖
計量
- 文章訪問數: 1408
- HTML全文瀏覽量: 672
- PDF下載量: 40
- 被引次數: 0
